Saturday, October 7, 2017

A SIMPLE QUESTION


October 6, 2017

Rep. Dana Rohrabacher,
101 Main Street #380
Huntington Beach, CA 92648

Dear Congressman,

Re: A simple question

Here’s a simple question for you: Is it okay with you that a foreign nation committed an act of war against the United States?

The act of war was not committed with conventional weapons, but with digital technology. The evidence for a series of cyberattacks in last year’s election is now overwhelming.

The evidence is also overwhelming that the act of war was committed by your friends in Russia.

It couldn’t get simpler than that.

So, Patriot, is this okay with you? Or is it still “baloney”?

Respectfully,


Peter Clothier, Ph.D.


Friday, October 6, 2017

BUMP STOCKS--NOT ENOUGH!

October 6, 2017

Rep. Dana Rohrabacher,
101 Main Street #380
Huntington Beach, CA 92648

Dear Congressman,

Re: Bump Stocks

Do NOT allow yourself think that it’s appropriate to use bump stocks as a way to avert more serious action on the much greater problem of guns in the United States. This, I believe, is the aim of the National Rifle Association, in suggesting support for a bump stock ban.

We need that, AND more comprehensive action. No one is opposed to the possession of firearms for the purpose of hunting. Most even defend the possession of handguns for the purpose of self-defense. I myself happen to dislike the whole notion of taking guns out into the forest to kill defenseless animals. And I believe that handguns in the home are more likely to cause unintended harm than to defend anyone. But I acknowledge those to be my views and do not seek to impose them on those who believe otherwise.

I do, however—along with a vast majority of my fellow citizens—believe that there should be reasonable regulations covering the purchase and possession of firearms. We require a competency test to drive a car; we require insurance for each vehicle; and we deny licenses to those deemed less than competent to drive, whether for physical or mental impairment. These are reasonable regulations, Yet we impose no such restrictions on the purchase of guns, at least at gun shows, where huge numbers of lethal weapons are bought and traded.

And there are firearms—such as those used by the Las Vegas killer—which simply do not belong in the hands of ordinary citizens. Their sale and purchase should be strictly regulated.

We are the only country in the world that permits this tragic, obscene, and seemingly ever increasing number of victims to gun violence to continue. It is time for you, as a member of Congress and my representative, to stand up against the gun lobby and join with others to ACT NOW to address this shameful issue.

Respectfully,



Peter Clothier, Ph.D.

Wednesday, October 4, 2017

WHAT I MEAN...


I'm not sure I made myself clear in yesterday's letter about the wrong questions and the right questions in the wake of the Las Vegas massacre. I wrote that the most frequently asked question (in the media at least) is "why." Understandably, because in a sense it's the most interesting question. When someone commits a crime of this magnitude, it's natural to want to know why.
But why? is, to my mind, a not very useful question. Even if we know exactly why--if the perpetrator, for example, writes a note saying: this is why I did it; or if he's a member of a terror organization; or a proven madman--even then, the answer doesn't help us. First, it's usually insufficient to account for the action. If we know it was committed by a terrorist, the why? question immediately crops up again: why was this man a terrorist? Then, even if we were to find a sufficient explanation, where does it get us? Does it even help us to prevent such events in the future? Probably not, because the next perpetrator will require different answers as to the why? of his action.
No, the real questions that need answers are the hows. How was this particular deranged man, the Las Vegas shooter, permitted to acquire the weapons to commit his atrocity? How did he manage to acquire such an arsenal (over 40 guns, as I understand it) without being noticed by authorities? How did he manage to gain access to that Las Vegas hotel room with so many lethal guns and so much ammunition? How could his crime have been forestalled? Prevented? (With reasonable regulations on the purchase and ownership of guns, perhaps).
It's the honest answers to these "how" (well, these other than "why"?) questions that would make it possible to address a problem--indeed, an epidemic--whose unimpeded growth is a disgraceful indictment of our society. In this, we are unenviably different from every other advanced nation. And yet, and still, the hows remain inexcusably unanswered; instead we get sidetracked with the "whys." Because they are more fascinating and, perhaps, because they will always be unanswerable.

Tuesday, October 3, 2017

WRONG QUESTION

October 3, 2017

Rep. Dana Rohrabacher,
101 Main Street #380
Huntington Beach, CA 92648

Dear Congressman,

Re: Wrong question

I’ve said this before and I very much fear I’ll have reason to say it again. This time, as always with mass shootings, we get obsessed with the wrong question. We ask: Why?

It’s natural, I suppose. It's the most interesting question, and it’s inevitable that we try to understand the motives for such demented, barbarous acts—acts that seem to defy the very roots of our common humanity. Trouble is, no matter how many explanations we come up with, nor how varied according to each individual tragedy, they always eventually fall short. It's essentially irrelevant to understanding, let alone finding the solution to the problem.

No, the real, the important question is not Why, but: How did this happen? How are these demented souls empowered to wreak the havoc they do? How do people, sometimes quite obviously unfit to be entrusted with deadly weapons, get the means in their hands to go out and kill? How is it that our country, all evidence to the contrary, continues to allow a small group of fanatics to persuade lawmakers, such as yourself, Congressman, to persist in the removal of even the sanest of regulations to keep us safe from such outrages?

Today, I hear the same tired old argument: now is not the time, in the wake of this current tragedy, the worst in our history, to “politicize” the issue. I disagree. Now is precisely the time. It’s a moral imperative. You, our representatives in Congress, must address it.

Respectfully,



Peter Clothier, Ph.D.

Monday, October 2, 2017

LAS VEGAS

October 2, 2017

Rep. Dana Rohrabacher,
101 Main Street #380
Huntington Beach, CA 92648

Dear Congressman,

Re: Las Vegas

Okay, I don’t know the facts. I just know the headlines. But it seems clear from the fact of “at least 50 dead” and “more than 400 injured” that the weaponry involved in the latest shooting outrage must have been more deadly in its firepower than any civilian should have had in his possession. I don’t know who the man is or was and I don’t care what his motivation might have been; he should never have been empowered to inflict this much human casualty.

Congressman, it is well past time for you and your colleagues to stand up to the gun lobby and say: “Enough!” Your latest action—to ease access to sound suppressors in the name of saving the hearing of those who enjoy target practice—is yet another move in the wrong direction. This latest incident brings with it a moral obligation to restore sanity to the purchase and possession of firearms in the United States. To do otherwise, capitulating to the extremist demands of lobbyists who represent the interests of the gun industry, is criminally irresponsible.

I am angry on behalf of an army of the needlessly slaughtered and the needlessly injured innocents—and I don’t mean just in Las Vegas: I mourn, still the children of Sandy Hook, whose deaths are still unaccounted for by the U.S. Congress.

In their name, and in the name of future victims to be spared, I demand that you act! Now!

With anger replacing my usual respect,


Peter Clothier, Ph.D.


Sunday, October 1, 2017

INSULTING?


October 2, 2017

 Rep. Dana Rohrabacher,
101 Main Street #380
Huntington Beach, CA 92648

Dear Congressman,

Re: Insulting?

Isn’t this a bit insulting? Gary Cohn, director of the National Economic Council, explained the other day that the typical American family making $100,000 per year would probably get a $1,000 tax cut next year, if the Trump tax “reform” plan is approved. He claimed that this would stimulate the economy as people would use the incredible windfall for things like kitchen renovations and buying new cars.

First: I very much doubt that the “typical American family” makes $100,000 a year. Most of them would be incredulous to hear they bring home this much. Next: by comparison, the “un-typical” American family—those bringing home $500,000 or more—could expect a disproportionately much huger tax cut. So Cohn expects this “typical” family to rejoice in their good fortune? This belongs in the classic “let them eat cake” category of condescension. And further: has Cohn ever renovated a kitchen or purchased a new car? For a $1,000, I suppose, you might be able to buy a faucet set, or get a just about working vintage junker?

There’s an attitude here, would you not agree, Congressman? The billionnaireTrump cabinet and other senior appointments speak from a place of great wealth, and with great condescension toward the hoi-polloi. Take, for instance, Betsy de Vos, speaking the other day at Harvard about the great promise of privatized education. She had the gall to cite the happy faces of the fortunate few non-billionaires who had won their place in private schools by lottery!

And then last week we learned about some of the extravagant perks expected by these people, as though it were their right, by privilege, to fly on private jets. As for the Trump family… well, don’t get me started.

Respectfully,




Peter Clothier, Ph.D.

Friday, September 29, 2017

DRAINING THE SWAMP


September 29, 2017


Rep. Dana Rohrabacher,
101 Main Street #380
Huntington Beach, CA 92648

Dear Congressman,

Re: Draining the swamp

So much for “draining the swamp,” eh?  What a farce that’s turning out to be! Your Trump’s top guys are busy enjoying extravagant perks at taxpayer expense. Trump and his family cashing in royally on the presidency. A tax “reform” proposal that promises to save them literally billions of dollars in estate taxes…

I’m sure that you, Congressman, would not stoop to such shenanigans. But how is it down in the swamp these days? Is it getting a little… smellier?

Respectfully,


Peter Clothier, Ph.D.


SPEAK OUT!

June 9, 2018 Rep. Dana Rohrabacher, 101 Main Street #380 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Dear Congressman, You may be surprise...