Tuesday, May 1, 2018
A NOTE TO READERS
If you heard last night about "The Rohrabacher Letters"--or if you have been reading them all along--please note that the letter I post below will be the last. I woke up this morning, May 1st, with the decision to "accentuate the positive," as the old song says, and change my blogging habits. Having now found my candidate for the coming primaries, I will be posting instead in Rooting for Dr. Hans. Please join me there.
MY LAST LETTER
April 30, 2018
Rep. Dana
Rohrabacher,
101 Main
Street #380
Huntington
Beach, CA 92648
Dear
Congressman,
Re: My last letter
I woke this morning with a momentous decision. This
will be the last letter that I write to you. Well, let me not say the last. An
occasion may yet arise when I feel the need to pass on an opinion or comment in
some way on your actions in Congress or your political campaign. But I have
decided to reorient my sense of civic responsibility. Instead of writing to you
and posting on “The Rohrabacher Letters,” I will be posting on a new blog,
“Rooting for Dr. Hans.”
I met Dr. Hans Keirstead at a meet-and-greet last
night. After weeks of indecision I realized I had found my candidate. He is
superbly educated, extraordinarily well-informed on a wide range of issues, and articulate
in expressing positions that I share. He is also a man of obvious compassion. I
intend to support him in every way I can in his effort to take your seat in
Congress.
My decision is based only in part on the fact that
you have responded to not a single one of letters—today’s is the 264th.
I recognize that you are busy, and that we differ on virtually every issue.
Still, I am a constituent, and it would have taken little time and effort on
your part to acknowledge, or have your staff acknowledge my concerns. Where I
come from (England) that would be called “good manners.”
So, no. My decision is based on my desire to shift
into a positive mode in my sense of civic duty. In the coming election,
particularly, I believe it important for Democrats to avoid the Trump- and
Republican-bashing that offers such a huge temptation. I think we should allow
you all to persist along your chosen path of self-destruction. There are so
many critical challenges to which Democrats can formulate sound and practicable
solutions that we would do well to offer those positive ideas to voters, to
replace the failed policies of the past.
So this will be goodbye, for now. I was getting a
bit bored, anyway, frankly. It will be a nice relief to release myself from
what had become an obligation rather than a pleasure.
Respectfully,
Peter Clothier, Ph.D.
Monday, April 30, 2018
SCIENCE
April 30, 2018
Rep. Dana
Rohrabacher,
101 Main
Street #380
Huntington
Beach, CA 92648
Dear
Congressman,
Re:
Science
I note
that the House of Representatives rejected your four amendments to the annual
FAA reauthorization bill, seeking to protect Orange County residents from the
noise pollution from aircraft taking off and landing at the John Wayne airport.
I wrote
about this last week. While the cause is a worthy one if taken in isolation, it
is minor when compared with the bigger picture. “The House chose the efficiency
of airplanes over your quality of life,” you complained to readers on your
Facebook page. And rightly so. Their vote opts for by far the lesser of two
evils. It is environmental folly to require aircraft to fly higher and wider
around our local airport, using more fuel and increasing carbon emission
pollution, in order to spare us (I include myself among those who dislike the
noise) some relatively speaking small
discomfort and annoyance.
In a
planetary emergency like the one we’re facing, we need to consider the quality
of life of all the world’s inhabitants, including our fellow-travelers in the
animal kingdom. We’re all in this together. We all need to breathe clean air.
We need clean water, and a stable climate. It’s not simply a concern for a
handful of, well, mostly quite comfortable human beings, thank you, in this
wealthy enclave of Southern California. That is, of course, if you believe the
science, which apparently many of your colleagues don’t.
How about
you, Congressman. Do you believe the science? Just wondering…
Respectfully,
Peter
Clothier, Ph.D.
Friday, April 27, 2018
THE SWAMP
Rep. Dana
Rohrabacher,
101 Main
Street #380
Huntington
Beach, CA 92648
Dear
Congressman,
Re: The
swamp
Here’s what Mick Mulvaney, head of the Office of Management and Budget
and temporary director of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, had to say the
other day to an audience of 1,300 bankers and lending officials: “We had a
hierarchy in my office in Congress. If you’re a lobbyist who never gave us
money, I didn’t talk to you. If you’re a lobbyist who gave us money, I might
talk to you.”
Which sheds some light on the fact that you have never once responded to
a single one of the more than 250 letters I have sent you. I never gave you
money. I’m guessing that, like Mulvaney, you talk only to those who do.
The stench from Trump’s swamp—the one he promised
to drain—grows more noxious by the day. Far from draining it, he has created
one so deep and malodorous, it outstinks any in the history of this suffering
country.
And what, may I ask, are you doing about it,
Congressman? I have not heard a single peep of protest or outrage from you.
Time to get out the air freshener (aerosol! Ugh!) and start spraying.
Best,
Wednesday, April 25, 2018
POLLUTION
April 25, 2018
Rep. Dana
Rohrabacher,
101 Main
Street #380
Huntington
Beach, CA 92648
Dear
Congressman,
Re: Okay, but…
I read your tweet yesterday about working to
“mitigate the increase of jet engine noise over our neighborhoods” and thought
to myself, “Okay, but…”
The “okay” is that it’s certainly a good thing to
reduce noise pollution—over our neighborhoods and elsewhere. It’s a good thing
to reduce every kind of pollution that impinges on our quality of life, whether
air, or noise, or light, or indeed any other form. Life in contemporary America
is hard enough. We have too many sources of stress, which result in all kinds
of uncivil behavior. The human species survived, evolved, even—if you happen to
believe in evolution, as I do and apparently a large number of Americans do
not—on a planet that did not have these particular health hazards, so our
bodies and minds are ill-prepared to accommodate to them.
So there is a “but.” There is, in my view, more
than a taste of “not in my back yard” provincialism to your pronouncement that
I find questionable. All very well to cater to the mild discomfort of our
generally wealthy and materially comfortable communities; but this should not
be accompanied by neglect of the huge problems of pollution that affect the
entire planet. While you, in comfortable Orange County, complain about the
noise of the jet planes that carry us in relative luxury and with amazing speed
on our trips throughout the planet, there are literally millions of human
beings who are forced to suffer the consequences of our national embrace of
fossil fuels and our failure to accept responsibility for our contribution to
world-wide pollution.
While you complain about the noise of take-off and
landing, you do nothing about the pollution that is distributed liberally in
the earth’s atmosphere in between.
Respectfully,
Peter Clothier, Ph.D.
Thursday, April 19, 2018
NIMBY
April 17, 2018
Rep. Dana Rohrabacher,
101 Main Street #380
Huntington Beach, CA 92648
Dear Congressman,
Re: NIMBY
I just came across your appalling statement from 23 March titled “Homeless Shelter Nonsense.” You write as “a parent who owns a modest home in an Orange County neighborhood,” protesting against “County homeless compounds setting up shop in our local communities” and calling this humanitarian action “a travesty.”
First, on purely moral grounds, whatever happened to Christian charity—or, for myself, Buddhist compassion? You call it “an outrage” to be “assuming responsibility for homeless people and taking care of their basic needs”—this, in one of the wealthiest communities in the entire country? The outrage, Congressman, is your outrage.
Next, is it not your job to represent all the people of your district, not merely the Republican or the rich ones? Not merely those fortunate enough to live in comfort, like yourself and your family? These people whom you so despise are also your constituents, Congressman. You “represent” them. My turn to be outraged, by your dismissal of their needs.
I find it difficult to believe that any responsible human being could have written such a screed, let alone one elected to the privilege of serving the people of our district.
Again, without too much respect this morning,
Peter Clothier, Ph.D.
Rep. Dana Rohrabacher,
101 Main Street #380
Huntington Beach, CA 92648
Dear Congressman,
Re: NIMBY
I just came across your appalling statement from 23 March titled “Homeless Shelter Nonsense.” You write as “a parent who owns a modest home in an Orange County neighborhood,” protesting against “County homeless compounds setting up shop in our local communities” and calling this humanitarian action “a travesty.”
First, on purely moral grounds, whatever happened to Christian charity—or, for myself, Buddhist compassion? You call it “an outrage” to be “assuming responsibility for homeless people and taking care of their basic needs”—this, in one of the wealthiest communities in the entire country? The outrage, Congressman, is your outrage.
Next, is it not your job to represent all the people of your district, not merely the Republican or the rich ones? Not merely those fortunate enough to live in comfort, like yourself and your family? These people whom you so despise are also your constituents, Congressman. You “represent” them. My turn to be outraged, by your dismissal of their needs.
I find it difficult to believe that any responsible human being could have written such a screed, let alone one elected to the privilege of serving the people of our district.
Again, without too much respect this morning,
Peter Clothier, Ph.D.
Wednesday, April 18, 2018
TIME TO LEAVE?
April 17, 2018
Rep. Dana
Rohrabacher,
101 Main
Street #380
Huntington
Beach, CA 92648
Dear
Congressman,
Re: Time to leave?
The number of Republican congressional
representatives who have decided to leave rather than face stiff reelection
odds in the fall continues to mount. Thus far, there are nearly 50 of them
making that considered decision. Which leads me to ask:
How about it, Congressman? Is it time to rethink your previously
announced decision not to leave? Or do you still think your surf-riding skills
will make it possible for you to ride the predicted Blue Tsunami? (For which,
by the way, along with many other Democrats, I am not holding my breath. We
also have serious work to do).
Respectfully,
Peter Clothier, Ph.D.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
SPEAK OUT!
June 9, 2018 Rep. Dana Rohrabacher, 101 Main Street #380 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Dear Congressman, You may be surprise...
-
April 30, 2018 Rep. Dana Rohrabacher, 101 Main Street #380 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Dear Congressman, Re: My las...
-
June 9, 2018 Rep. Dana Rohrabacher, 101 Main Street #380 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Dear Congressman, You may be surprise...
-
If you heard last night about "The Rohrabacher Letters"--or if you have been reading them all along--please note that the letter I...